
Moonshining In Kentucky's Clay County
Date: Tuesday, July 27 @ 23:26:20 CDT Topic: Feature Stories
Moonshining in Kentucky's Clay County "The Sheriff On The Spot" By: Col. T. C. Sizemore
Contributing writer, Thomas C. Sizemore, age 89, is a veteran journalist and a writer of vast experience and creativity. Col. Sizemore owned and operated weekly newspapers in Kentucky and Tennessee, over a span of 40 years. Sizemore also served as Area correspondent for "Time" and "Life" magazines. A Native of Clay County, Kentucky, Col. Sizemore saw action in the Western Pacific, under Gen. Douglas McArthur, during World War II. Subsequent to the war, Col. Sizemore ran for the office of sheriff and became famous for his campaign against moonshine traffickers in Clay County.
Moonshining in Kentucky's Clay County "The Sheriff On The Spot" By: Col. T. C. Sizemore
To be high sheriff of one of the mountain counties in Kentucky, during the heyday of the moonshine traffic, was to live at the vortex of wildly agitated passions and events. But to better comprehend that volatile carburetion of time, fervor and circumstance, as well as the dangers it posed for law-enforcement officers, it is necessary to reflect upon the social, cultural and historical ferment that produced the mountain people themselves.

Sheriff Sizemore samples confiscated "shine" as trusted deputies, (L to R: Ford Collett, Charlie Byrd and Cecil Martin) look on.... Photo courtesy of Lexington Herald-Leader - Dec. 20, 1958

TODAY - Clay County Sheriffs face a similar type problem only with different products such as marijuana and "deadly" methamphetamine. Former Sheriff Edd Jordan is shown here with a confiscated "pot" plant complete with buds. Photo courtesy of These Truckin' Times Febuary issue 1996
Daniel Boone passed through the Cumberland Gap and penetrated into the Bluegrass country in 1769. Boone, the members of his party and the straggling handfuls of settlers who immediately followed, were a hardy, adventurous breed, to be sure. But they were also many other things; they were ruffians, cutthroats, trappers, traders and ordinary men and women who, seeing the clouds of war with England massing on the eastern horizon, had decided that it was a propitious time to push westward.....
DARK AND BLOODY GROUND
But for whatever their reasons in coming west, their coming was viewed as a trespass by the Shawnee, Iroquois, Cherokee and other American Indian tribes who had long coveted and contested possession of this "dark and bloody ground." Many battles would be fought and much blood would stain the earth in purchase of the first meager settlements in Kentucky.
INTERMARRIAGES WERE NOT UNCOMMON
Not withstanding the strife between Kentucky settlers and American Indians they sought to displace, intermarriages were not uncommon. And the fusions of these bloods, over many generations, would lend their strenth and character to many Kentucky families.
By the end of the Revolutionary War in 1783, settlers were floating down the rivers and swarming through the Cumberland Gap to expand the first tenuous settlements. Originally, all settlements in Kentucky had political ties to Virginia. These ties were severed in 1792 when Kentucky became the 15th state of the Union.
HARDSHIPS, HEARTACHES AND DANGERS
Most of the hardships, heartaches and dangers attending the lives of the early settlers served to strengthen their bonds and to fortify their resolve as wilderness people. It was not until the advent of the Civil War in 1861, that Kentuckians would be confronted by socio-political events, the puissance of which would shatter this wilderness solidarity. For, although Kentucky never seceded from the Union,and although most Kentuckians fought on the side of the Union, thousands of Kentuckians marched off to fight for the Confederacy. And the peculiar bitterness engendered by that fratricidal war created familial wounds and social schisms, many of which would remain unhealed and disjoined across the span of generations.
TIME CREEPS, SORE FOOTED AND WEARY
Those eastern Kentucky natives who survived the carnage of the Civil War limped homeward with broken bodies, minds and spirits, to the verdant haunts and hollows of the Appalachian Highlands. There in their mountain fastnesses where time creeps sore footed and weary, and change comes grudgingly like a stubborn child, those war-ravaged veterans turned to the task of eking out their meager existence in an unyielding, unsparing land....
COAL, TOBACCO AND WHISKEY
The state-wide economy, founded principally upon the pillars of coal, horses, tobacco and whiskey, remained cruelly depressed in the Appalachian region. There was timber in the mountains and abundant coal beneath it, but all to often these mountain treasures were syphoned off by carpetbagging interests from outside the region or state, leaving the mountain people with nightmarish moonscapes of denuded hills and orphan banks, and bitter resentment towards outsiders.
INFAMOUS FOR POVERTY
Generation after generation of mountain people saw their lives misshaped by the mean subsistence of abject poverty for which the region had long since become infamous. Sons followed their fathers down into the bowels of the earth, scratching out their meager livings and--all to often--digging their own tombs, while mountain wives and mothers listened guardedly for the first crushing rumors of disaster. An endless succession of foreign wars hurled mountain sons into the breeches of enemy canons, leaving foreign beaches wet with blood, and the mountains wet with tears.. And in a land where hopes was fleeting as a fox before hard-pressing hounds, bitterness and despair became bred into a people.
TRAPPERS BARTER WHISKEY
Then there was whiskey in the mountains--red and white. Always in the mountains there had been whiskey. The earliest trappers and traders had bartered whiskey to the American Indians for furs and other native goods, while the domestic manufacture of liquor--like the making of homemade bread--had persisted in rural America since Colonial times. And, to the extent that this practice predated the goverment and govermental decree, it was held by many rural Americans to be a right transcendent to the regulatory powers of the goverment.
"ILLEGAL" WHISKEY
The prodigious growth in the manufacture of "illegal" whiskey that erupted in the border states, the south and southwest, is believed to have been a reaction to heavy federal liquor taxes levied in 1862. In some places, and at least to some degree, the manuefacture of non-revenue whiskey was an atempt to thwart Union war efforts. Dubbed "moonshine" because it had to be manufactured secretly--often at night and by the light of the moon--this illlicit liquor would flourish far beyond the war that accelerated its production. And nowhere would it flourish more notable than in the Appalachian region of Kentucky.
JENNY BARNS AND HONKY-TONKS
Yes, there was whiskey in the mountains--red and white. And there were road houses, jenny barns and honky-tonks of every description--places where men and women so inclined could temporarily anesthetize themselves from lives attended by hardships and sorrows. And the whiskey would mingle with the hardships, sorrow, bitterness and resentment; the fists would fly; the guns would blaze; women would scream; and red blood would flow with the whiskey--red and white.
COMMODITY ROLLS SWELL TO 5,000
Compounding the daily hardships of mountainlife, a massive rail strike in the 1950s profoundly affected the coal industry and smaller businesses, throwing hundreds of people out of work. The commodity rolls swelled from 4,000 to 5,000 persons, desperately in need of goverment surplus foods such as flour, meal, cheese, peanut butter, pork and other meat products. Hunger and uncertainty created enormous social pressures--pressures which often as not, manifested themselves in increased drinking and the concomitant increase in domestic and other forms of violence. Family feuds would erupt without warning--often with a tragic loss of life. Every week saw someone assaulted, shot or killed. And in all to many instances the pale specter of white whiskey loomed over the violence.....
Caught in the middle of this mindless bloodletting and bottomless despair were thousands of decent, God-fearing mountian people who only wanted to provide secure and safe environments for their families, to rear and educate their children, and to live quiet, honorable lives. It was the frustrated yearnings of these fine people that brought my blood to a boil and set me on the campaign trail.
FIRST RUN FOR SHERIFF
My first campaign for sheriff was unsuccessful; I lost the election by a total of 250 votes. In 1957, I ran again. Facing 10 candidates, and with both of the county's political machines against me, I won by a landslide. The entire election only cost me $895.43. Running on a platform of strict law-enforcement, I was given a mandate by the people. I, in turn, gave the people my word. Others had given their word in the past. The difference was that I meant it!
COURIER JOURNAL CITES SHERIFF
In this article entitled "Sheriff on the Spot," Joe Creason chronicled my initial raid in the March 1, 1957 edition of the Courier Journal: "No sooner had he put on the sheriff's badge than he began to police his county the way he talks--fast, in a hurry. His first raid was against a 300-gallon moonshine operation."
After busting my first moonshine operation, I immediately struck at the red legally manufactured whiskey illegally sold or possessed in a dry county. As the Creason article noted, I didn't want it said that I was in the pocket of the bootleggers. My raid against a local truck stop netted an otherwise insignificant quantity of beer and red whiskey. But it put the word out that I was riding against any and all who violated liquor laws in Clay County.
The importance of the fight that my deputies and I were waging was poignantly driven home shortly after my being sworn in as sheriff. We received a call to come to Big Creek where two young men were found dead as a result of drinking poisoned moonshine. Investigation revealed that the moonshine was contaminated with acid and lye, and the young men had drunk enough to kill them instantly.
MAJOR ASHER FINEST KSP COMMANDER
Major Doug Asher, the finest State Police commander ever to serve this area, recently pointed up the inherent danger of moonshine consumption: "Drinking moonshine has always been an extreme health risk, and probably more so in this modern day and time. Fewer people are knowledgeable in the correct operation of stills. Some have used car radiatiors during the distillation process, causing lead poisoning and even death from the consumption of the whiskey. At best, the lack of quality control and lack of sanitary conditions during manufacturuing should cause people to think twice before consuming home made whiskey."
NUMEROUS DEATHS FROM BAD MOONSHINE
The lack of quality control in moonshine production has historically posed a grave public danger. Few moonshiners utilized all-copper stills. Car batteries and raidiators, acid, lye, dead animals and many things unspeakable, were reportedly involved in moonshine productions. During my term as sheriff there were three or four dead from bad moonshine, and numerous persons made sick and hospitalized.
MAN FOUND BURNED TO DEATH AT STILL
Although we vigorously investigated the deaths in the Big Creek incident and intensified raids in the area, no one would talk, and we were never able to get a lead on the person who produced that batch of poison. However, near Paw Paw, five miles west of Manchester, a man was found burned to death at a still, his clothing apparently set afire. Even among outlaws there are laws and, not infreqently, a rough brand of justice.
"SHERIFF, SEE YOU IN CHURCH SUNDAY
Aided by the State Police and State Alcoholic Beverage control (ABC) agents, we pressed the attack, conducting 14 raids in 18 hours, during one period. At a 50-gallon still near Manchester we once apprehended an eight year-old boy. He was all alone and "running off the shine." The judge ordered us to take him back to the area and let him find his way back home. It worked.
We scouted a 50-gallon still in the Morgan Branch area of the county one Sunday morning. When we arrived at the still no one was around, but a note attached to a tree read, "Sheriff, see you in church, Sunday." It was a subtle way of reminding us that the people that we were pursuing were our own friends, neighbors, and quite possibly--family members.
DON'T BOTHER STABLE, MULE WILL KICK YOU
ALong the Clay-Knox County lines, we had a warrant to search the premises of a man believed to be a moonshiner. The deputies became suspicious when the man warned them not to bother the stable, because the mule would kick them. They located a pitchfork, got the mule turned around and discovered four gallons of the shine buried in the stall....
SHINERS OFF WITH A WARNING
Although determined to rid Clay county of moonshine, I was not without compassion for some of the poor men in the area--men who were only making a little shine to feed and clothe their wives and kids. Often, I would let them off with a warning, or ask the judge to dismiss charges against them. But I gave no quarter to the big operators, some of who sold white lightning in Ohio and surrounding states.
At Ephran's Branch many stills were located, a considerable amount of moonshine confiscated and many persons arrested. But the moonshiners were undeterred. If anything, our activity seemed to harden their resolve, and things got dangerous in a hurry.
Within a month of my taking office and initiating my anti-liquor crusade, I began recieving threats by telephone or through communications directed through friends or other third-parties. Some of the warnings were vaguely articulated, while others graphically predicted my violent death--if I didn't back off.
WHILE DAD LAY DYING, KILLERS BEAT HIS HEAD IN WITH RIFLES
No one acquainted with the violent history of this region could dismiss these threats as idle huffing and puffing. My own father, Carlo L. Sizemore, a deputy sheriff who had served the region for 20 years, under five sheriffs, had been gunned down on November 12, 1931, while traveling the rugged country roads to secure a warrant of arrest in an election-day altercatoin. Ambushed from a hillshide near the George Kelly residence on Goose Rock, seven miles southeast of Manchester, he was struck several times by high powered rifle fire, and knocked from his mule. As he lay on the ground dying, his killers walked up to him, and one of them beat a rifle barrel over his head. Neighbors heard my father praying for mercy and begging for help.
HIGH SHERIFF KILLED IN LINE OF DUTY
In the approximiately 50 years prior to my assuming the office of sheriff, at least 20 deputies had been killed in the line of duty and an untold number wounded. A police judge, a police chief, and a few police had also been killed during that period. Only one high sheriff was killed in the line of duty.
I had only been 10 years old when my father was killed; and while it was incomprehensible to me then, that there existed a wild and desperate element in the characters of certain mountain people, that sometimes leads itself to acts of savagery, but the time I had pinned on the badge of sheriff, the naivete and terror of a 10-year old boy had been put far behind me. I was the high sheriff of Clay county, and there would be no compromise with terror!
We struck hard at the liquor-law violators. During the first 15 months that I was in office, we seized and destroyed 120 stills, made almost 300 raids against bootlegging operations, and arrested more than 1,000 violators of liquor laws and other laws.
DYNAMITE BLASTS CAR
But the liquor law violators struck back. One or two sticks of dynamite thrown from a moving vehicle did about $300 damage to my car, but I escaped injury. Several months later, I narrowly escaped death when a much heavier explosion destroyed my car, blowing pieces of the vehicle over the courthouse. The charge had been placed beneath the front seat, and only a chance visitor had delayed my routine suficiently that I was not in the vehicle when it exploded.

This 1958 Ford Fairlane was destroyed by a bomb blast intended to put Sheriff Sizemore out of the business of destroying stills. Photo courtesy of The Courier- Journal, Louisville, KY - Feb. 12, 1959.
THREATENING TELEPHONE CALLS
The horrific blast that destroyed my car made me realize the deadly seriousness of the threats made against my life. I responded by adopting the stringent security measures. The threats persisted; sometimes I'd receive two or three threatening phone calls a week.
Late one might at my apartment atop Courthouse Hill, I heard some men trying to break into my apartment. They would leave and come back. I left by the front door and spent the night with a friend. Three days later a neighbor, who ran a nearby furniture store, reported seeing two men leave the building around 2:00 a.m. but thought they were two of my deputies. I kept confiscated beer and whiskey in one of the rooms of the apartment, but nothing was disturbed. The men had apparently come to kill the sheriff.....
LURED INTO HILLS
Efforts to lure me out into the countryside to kill me became commonplace. Around midnight once, I received a call reporting that someone had shot into a local bootlegger's house, killing an old woman and couple of kids. I told the caller that I would ask the State police to respond as quickly as possible, but I told my deputy not to go. I was convinced that it was an attempt to lure my deputy and me into an ambush. My suspicions were confirmed when the State Police reported that there had been no shooting at the residence.
After leaving office, I was informed by an ex-lawman that there had been men on the bridge overlooking the house, waiting to kill my deputy and me, the moment we stepped out of our car. I was even provided with the names of those would be killers.
My security concerns were compounded by my marriage, after the first year in office. With a wife, a newborn son and a six-year old stepson to care for, I was quick to learn that, to the extent that a man has loved ones, to the same extent is he vulnerable. Now death could walk through any one of several doors; and wherever I rode, fear rode with me.
VIGIL MAINTAINED WHILE MY WIFE AND I SLEPT
Nothing could be left to chance. If we left our home or our car unattended, they were checked out by deputies before we re-entered them. Every telephone call had to be screened. We would reguarly change rooms in our home, never staying in the same part of the house for long at a time. Often one of my deputies was on duty at my house, maintaining vigil while my wife and I slept.
Yet no amount of vigilance could guarantee safety. On at least two occasions I came under fire, but escaped the hail of bullets. My deputies were often fired upon and occasionally wounded. Late one afternoon, one deputy was shot and another cut badly in a remote hollow. On yet another occasion, two deputies and a constable were picking up beer cans along a hillside at Pigeon Roost, when they were ambushed and wounded. The Constable was badly wounded, but recovered. And, while I was away in Middlesboro attending a trial, my house on Island Creek, near Fox Hollow was destroyed by fire.
$25,000 REWARD OFFERED TO KILL SHERIFF
Three days before I left office of Sheriff in 1961, a local restaurant owner, just outside of town, asked me to come by, saying that he had something important to tell me. When I arrived his wife informed me that he was in the kitchen drinking coffee. There was another man with him when I walked into the room. I asked what was up, and the restaurant owner stated that he wanted the man with him to tell me just how close I had come to getting killed. I was told that another local man had offered $10,000 to have my chief deputy killed and another $25,000 to have me killed. I was also told that the price of killing the chief deputy had been agreed upon, but that the killer had insisted upon $50,000 to kill the high sheriff. The killings were to have been a package deal, and all that had prevented the snuffing of two lives, had been the failure to meet the price the killer had placed on the head of the sheriff. I was given the name of the men who had offered the bounty, and when I asked the identify of man who was to have done the killing, the informant answered, "I'm the man." He looked me right into the eyes and never blinked. To this day I visualize those cold, unblinking eyes--passionless as the eyes of a rag doll or a shark--counting the price of two men's lives, and leveling over the sights of a gun.
OUTLAW CROWD AFRAID OF DEPUTY
After leaving office I owned and operated a newspaper down in Tennessee for awhile. Upon my returning to Clay County, a friend of mine asked me to meet him at a restaurant out in the county. We met, over a meal my friend informed me that without that "tough" deputy of mine, I would surely have been killed. he insisted that there was one of my deputies of whom the outlaw crowd had been deathly afraid.
During my term as sheriff of Clay County, I had beeen served by a number of tough deputies--men like Charlie Byrd, Robert Carnahan Sr., Ford Collett, Jim Collett, Chester Gregory, Homer mills, Fed Nolan, Cecil Martin, Carl Rutledge, Robert (Bob Dock) Samples, Kenneth Jackson, Lewis Holland, Albert Bishop, Bill Whitehead, Alex Bowling, Lee Smith and Woodson Smith.
No one appreciated their courage and dedication to duty more so than did I. On the spot and virtually under siege, we had stood shoulder-to-shoulder through a turbulent and dangerous period in Clay County's history.
|